Skip to content

There’s No Compelling Reason for Americans to Watch Soccer

June 27, 2010

Like many American kids, I grew up playing soccer. Kids learn foot-eye coordination faster than hand-eye, so it’s natural to give them a ball to kick. I loved the competitive nature of the sport, and played for many years, and did some traveling, until I took up a new hobby. It’s such a fun sport to play. When you travel to a foreign country, there’s always someone playing a pick-up match, and you can join in the fun.

But as a packaged product to watch, soccer is designed to fail with the American sports audience. It goes beyond being boring. There are institutional things that the major sports here have adopted that make a huge difference in how one feels watching a game. The U.S. loss to Ghana highlighted some of those problems.

U-S-A! U-S-A! U-S-awwwww fuck!

First, delaying of games is simply not tolerated. In basketball, a team must bring the ball across half court within 8 seconds, and the ball must touch the rim within 24, or you lose possession. In football, you have a play clock where not calling a play on time results in a penalty. These rules prevent teams from just stalling to waste the game clock.

Sure, gamesmanship is part of the game, part of the coaching strategy. But there are limits. American sports force the action to continue. But in soccer, Ghana went well beyond what Americans would consider acceptable delay: acting hurt and falling on the ground when no opposing player was in the vicinity, then forcing a stretcher to carry you off, having a player shake hands before he’s substituted off the field, things like that. And the ref just stands there and lets it happen. This is absurd, and would never, ever be tolerated in the popular sports here. I racked my brain trying to determine why something so obviously detrimental to the enjoyment of the sport is allowed. It’s just stupid.

Second, non-stop 45 minute halves are a mirage. It appears as if the game is going faster. After all, the time DOESN’T STOP. And the match is over in just 90 minutes. But this denies something that Americans secretly value: breaks. No one likes commercials, but people need breaks, time-outs, to hit the restroom, go grab another beer, or go to the concession stand.

With frequent breaks, it feels as if time is moving faster, even though an NFL game can last 3 hours. But while watching soccer, it’s the same tick-tick-tick off the clock. Breaks allow for a release of emotion, and a little relaxation. Soccer prevents that from happening. Give us our breeaaaaakkkssss!!!

"I will take 91 minutes before I score."

Next, the overtime session is just stupid. Say what you want about the sudden-death NFL rules that were just modified. But that meant that every possession mattered. If you’re going to make a stop, it has to be now. The U.S. soccer team, though, seemed to say “ahhh let them score, we have 30 minutes to tie it.” 30 more minutes. Come on. The game should be decided before then. It’s not a knock-out, drag-out overtime where the pressure’s on. There’s no pressure with 30 minutes.

Finally, the flopping is just too much. Taking a foul and letting the refs know it happened, OK sure. It happens in the NBA all the time. But you wouldn’t think those guys were straight-up pussies.

Turn on soccer, and these guys will fall to the ground, crying, clutching body parts, without being touched. This is ridiculous. It happened in yesterday’s game: dude just falls down after messing up his own bicycle kick, rolls over to see how the play is turning out, then rolls back on his back, and lays there. That’s just one example.

For American males, sports is about showing off the manliness. There’s no manliness on display in soccer. It’s fine that it’s a finesse sport. But you know that none of these players have balls. They don’t act like men on the field. Take a hit and dish it back.

A real foul, that might lead to a real fight.

Every 4 years it’s the same question: is this the year Americans fall in love with soccer? It takes people 4 years to forget why they don’t tune in. But after watching a few matches, those memories of disgust return.

The NBA Finals are over. The NFL doesn’t start for a couple more months. Baseball is dull right now. I guess I’ll have to watch tennis until the fall.

Come on titty.

23 Comments leave one →
  1. June 27, 2010 11:35 am

    Interesting perspective. I used to hate on soccer, but I’m slowing warming up to it, and I’m writing this as I watch Germany dismantle England. I disagree with the thing about breaks though, mostly because it just gets so ridiculous at the end of an NBA game, when the last 40 seconds are dragged out to ten minutes and there are constant commercials. I can’t stand that. As for the extratime rules.. Eh, I don’t know if I agree with or what FIFA has in place. It’s kind of like extra innings in baseball, or in college football how each time gets one possession to match or beat the other time’s score. You didn’t touch on this at all, but the lack of instant replay no matter the situation, even when it affects goals, is just ridiculous. I don’t understand how FIFA doesn’t have extra refs at the goals or something to prevent things like the two disallowed American goals. I 100% completely agree with you about the fouls though. I didn’t realize soccer players also had to classically trained actors until this World Cup.

    Good post!

    ~ Sarah

    P.S. I love your captions, but Landon Donovan is #10 and even if he did wait 91 minutes to score, it was awesome!

  2. June 27, 2010 1:41 pm

    You make some good points. The only time I ever watch soccer is during the World Cup.

    What really surprises me is that you played it so much, but watching it still irritates you. I never really played soccer, but playing the FIFA video games is fun.

    • June 27, 2010 6:04 pm

      different perspective when you step back and take a birds-eye view. and it’s always more fun doing than watching

  3. Jesus permalink
    June 27, 2010 5:22 pm

    Americans need instant gratification NOW!, no NOW!, no NOW!. I think that sitting down for 90+ minutes without anything happening until the last moment goes against everything American. When you are used to easy and constant entertainment soccer is incredibly boring to watch. That is the reason that soccer will never be really popular in the U.S..

    Sure one team can grab the ball and waste time, but you can only do that if you are the better team. You need to have the ball to waste time. That is why North Korea didn’t try to waste time.

    Over dramatization of fouls happen, but a lot of the time the refs will just let the player lay on the ground.

    When you look at two teams that aren’t World Cup final material and base your argument of the sport on it you are going to stumble across the issues you highlighted. Keep watching the World Cup and you might enjoy watching the sport.

    But then again, there is no compelling reason for Americans to watch the sport.

    • June 27, 2010 6:15 pm

      it may seem unfair to judge the whole sport based on the first 2 rounds, but we have to be realistic. these are the best teams because they qualified for the tourney in the first place.

      watching these lower rounds is exactly what I’m supposed to be doing. I was intrigued, so I tuned in, instead of waiting for the championship round. i kept watching. and while before i was rather indifferent, now i’m just turned off. i want to be entertained, not put off. I don’t have time to learn to like it, especially when there are better options.

      My main point isn’t that the sport itself is bad. It’s the packaged product offered by FIFA. Some rules changes might help it be more entertaining. Hell, even Pele said years ago that widening the nets should be explored to make it more exciting. That’s the greatest soccer player ever admitting that watching it takes work.

      • Jesus permalink
        June 27, 2010 6:36 pm

        The teams that made to the second stage are not the best of the world, they are the best in their groups, I don’t think that you can say that Côte d’Ivoire is worse than the U.S. or Ghana, just because they didn’t classify. Argentina vs. Mexico today was a really good game, I think that soccer can and is boring a lot of the time, but you have to know what games to watch. I’m not watching Netherlands vs. Slovakia or Japan vs. Paraguay, because they are not really good teams.

        Any game played by Brazil, Portugal, Argentina, and maybe Germany is going to be very entertaining.

        Now there is no option to tie, so the teams have to give it their all, as you can tell by scores (Germany vs. England was 4-1 and Argentina vs. Mexico was 3-1). Teams have to stop playing defensively and start attacking, which creates spaces in the back to really create great plays, and goals.

        I am a huge fan of Barcelona and European soccer, but I didn’t watch all of the Champions Cup, I only watched the quarter finals, hell I won’t even watch all of the Peruvian soccer games, even though I am really passionate about Universitario.

        The main issue I have with FIFA is the ridiculous stance they have against technology being used in the game. But then again soccer is also about getting away with as much as you can pull off without the refs watching.

        The time to watch the World Cup is now, when the stakes are high and there is only one chance. I would suggest you keep watching, it is going to get really interesting from now on, maybe pick a team to cheer for.

        Ultimately if soccer bores you, oh well.

  4. June 27, 2010 6:22 pm

    Rookie you mad that Ghana won?

    lol just kidding

    Just playing, I left in Germany as youngster, so I got into the sport, once I moved here though I became “Americanized” and loved football and Basketball ever since. Soccer is to slow for me at times. I think if they got rid of the offside rule that be cool. But that’s just me, and lol @ the handshaking.

    • June 27, 2010 8:04 pm

      without the offside rule, there would be constant cherry-picking, which is far worse

  5. June 27, 2010 6:42 pm

    This has been a terrible World Cup.

    The horns have destroyed the ability of the players to communicate to each other on the pitch and have led to so many blunders and killed a lot of the creative play. There’s a lot of 11 men behind the ball and long shotting. Dull.

    The match officials are beyond awful. So many disallowed goals that should have counted, and LOL offside goals that were let to stand. The refs have headsets, but it appears to only be used for their iPods. Just disgraceful in this day and age.

    The horns just sound awful.

    • June 27, 2010 8:06 pm

      the horns have been a pain in the ass. it takes away from the natural highs and lows, cheering, silence, boos, and replaces it with a constant, emotion-numbing hum. i didn’t mention it though because that’s really on the fans

  6. June 27, 2010 8:10 pm

    I will watch Brazil

  7. Patric permalink
    June 28, 2010 7:02 am

    I’ve always liked your sentiments and view points about women, feeling that they are applicable in a broad spectrum regardless of where one was in the world. However in this case the one sided American view point is disappointing, but I figure as it’s an American blog, we have to make due with a narrow American perspective.

    Soccer is the most popular sport in the world, and the world cup is comparable only to the Olympics, yet you with typical American vision, in my view point, find the game boring, a game that captivates millions of people world wide. The Germany England game was insane, so was Argentina Mexico.

    You talk about a sport being manly, talk about rugby that is played on a much wider level that American football, you guys suck at this as well, why is that? Because you have 40 minutes of non stop playing time? Rugby is played without Helmets or padding. I agree with Jesus that most sports you mention are indeed targeted at an audience with a significant short attention span and a craving for instant gratification.

    We the rest of the world will keep watching our 90 minutes of football and 80 minutes of rugby. You on the other hand should keep to writing on women and game, which is why we all came to enjoy your blog in the first place.

  8. Patric permalink
    June 28, 2010 7:05 am

    P.s, the horns are part of South African fan culture, it brings a whole different atmosphere to the sport, different cultures, one sport uniting the world, players and teams having to adapt to different countries, altitudes, temperatures and fans, after what what else is the point of a ‘World” cup?

  9. Eamon permalink
    June 28, 2010 10:25 am

    Interesting. I can’t say I fully understand your sentiment, since I was raised on continents where if you didn’t play “football” [what soccer is called everywhere else] there was something wrong with you. I’m fine with just the one 15 minute break between halves. The NFL and especially the NBA are examples of breaks getting out of hand ["TV breaks", really?]
    However if you start by NOT watching the World Cup and watching some European domestic leagues, such as the English and Spanish ones that are easily accessible here instead, you’ll see some of the misconceptions dispelled, especially the rolling around. I’ve seen tons of players break fibulas [twice], play with stitches in their heads right after getting kicked in the head, etc. Different countries approach the sport in a unique way, and many do not condone the rolling around.
    The thing is that soccer is one of those deceptively easy sports. People watch and say “I can do that”, but give them a ball and a 115 yard pitch then they realize it’s actually demanding on the body.
    FIFA does need to add the extra refs and go back to sanctioning leather balls, not beachballs. I’ll agree FIFA hustles the game as a ‘product’, but every league does the same…

  10. BillyButts permalink
    June 28, 2010 7:15 pm

    You are not American.
    You are an Indian faggot.

  11. July 2, 2010 12:22 am

    Nicely written, good argument.

    My family is from South America, and I love soccer as much as I love the NFL. The beautiful game has gotten way too defensive in my opinion, it really is not so beautiful any more.

    Still, the suspense, the buildup, the tension, the fatigue, the frustration, the absurdity, all of it is part of soccer, just like it is part of life. There was fantastic article in the New Yorker about soccer years ago that explained it very well. Soccer is not to be enjoyed, it is to be experienced.

  12. July 4, 2010 4:11 pm

    Great post. I hate soccer. And you forgot to mention one thing: American’s also hate soccer because the rest of the world keeps trying to call it football.

  13. July 4, 2010 5:38 pm

    I love soccer but this World Cup just showed how behind they are w/the rules. How the fuck do they let Uruguay’s blatant hand ball cost Ghana the game. Just give them the fuckin’ goal, no need to do PKs.

  14. August 26, 2010 3:55 pm

    Americans can whine all they want but practically the entire world loves the game. Football (soccer) can and will continue to prosper without the USA. NFL-style football, however, nobody else wants that except, well, Canadians.

  15. Greg permalink
    September 30, 2010 7:16 am

    It’s not Football or Soccer, the real name is Association Football, normally the word Association is just dropped, just like Rugby Football, we tend to drop the Football.

    I’m surprised Rugby hasn’t taken on in the USA to be honest, or at least Rugby League which is a way faster version of the game.

    Anyway, association football is a money rich sport, and played on 99% of the planet, it’s not going away, not even from the USA, but I always feel there is room for other sports in all countries, because kids have different skills to fill them.

Trackbacks

  1. Linkage is Good for You: Seasons of Tumult and Discord Goes Tango Uniform Edition (NSFW)
  2. Weekend Link Fest – Stars and Stripes edition « Seasons of Tumult and Discord

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38 other followers